E-mail Advertising Audits: Every thing You Want To Know – E-mail Advertising – SMTP companies

News Author

What mysteries lie amongst your model’s electronic mail advertising statistics? What truths may you uncover in the event you discover the efficiency, deliverability, and design of every marketing campaign? You’ll solely know in the event you conduct an electronic mail advertising audit.

Okay, so an electronic mail audit isn’t fairly that magical. If it is a undertaking it’s essential full, and also you’re feeling a bit reluctant or overwhelmed, we completely perceive. Nevertheless, altering your perspective on electronic mail auditing goes to assist. When you get into it, you’ll begin revealing each issues that signify alternatives for enchancment in addition to successes that you need to use elsewhere in your electronic mail technique.

Mailjet’s unique report, Inbox Insights 2022, discovered even the most-successful electronic mail entrepreneurs face challenges equivalent to growing engagement, bettering accessibility, and fixing deliverability points. An electronic mail audit is an efficient approach to perceive and overcome these sorts of challenges.

On this complete article, we’ll check out every thing it’s essential find out about electronic mail advertising audits.

What’s an electronic mail audit?

First issues first – how do you outline an electronic mail advertising audit?

Whereas it may entail a wide range of totally different facets primarily based in your objectives, an electronic mail audit is an in-depth analysis of an electronic mail program together with the technique and assets that help it. The aim of auditing your electronic mail advertising efforts is commonly to uncover issues that have to be up to date or fastened.

Through the electronic mail auditing course of, you’ll uncover what’s working and what’s not. Plus, you may assess how effectively you might be following electronic mail advertising greatest practices that help components equivalent to higher engagement, larger deliverability charges, constant branding, compliance, safety, and way more.

Once you full your electronic mail audit, it’s best to have a a lot clearer image of how effectively your technique is (or isn’t) performing and an motion plan for making enhancements.

Why are electronic mail advertising audits essential?

To many outsiders, sending electronic mail appears so easy. However electronic mail entrepreneurs such as you perceive that there are a lot of complexities concerned in successfully delivering messages to subscribers’ inboxes. If we could also be completely blunt… there’s rather a lot that may go flawed in electronic mail advertising.

quote mark email security

“E-mail is a advertising and communication channel with an enormous return on funding, so an electronic mail audit is certainly price your effort and time.”

E-mail is continually evolving. There are at all times rising electronic mail developments or know-how, new compliance pointers and safety considerations, and even shifting help from electronic mail purchasers. You may’t simply “set it and overlook it” with electronic mail advertising. However that’s not the one motive to conduct an electronic mail advertising audit. Your model is continually altering and so are subscriber behaviors and preferences.

Adjustments embrace updates to the web site, recent content material to your emails, revised model fashion guides, in addition to new go-to-market methods and product roadmaps. An electronic mail advertising audit might help you retain your technique in alignment with all this stuff.

How typically do you have to conduct an electronic mail audit?

Most electronic mail consultants counsel conducting a complete electronic mail audit not less than annually. After all, you have to be holding a detailed eye on electronic mail analytics and efficiency always. However, taking a holistic take a look at your total program frequently is totally different.

The top/starting of the 12 months (December or January) is often time to conduct an electronic mail audit. Hopefully, by this time, you’ll have an thought of the general advertising technique in addition to the funds and expectations for the e-mail staff within the 12 months forward.

For bigger organizations that ship a excessive quantity of emails, bi-annual electronic mail advertising audits permit for a mid-year check-in.

New job. New electronic mail advertising audit.

One other essential time to conduct an electronic mail audit is if you begin working for a brand new employer or get promoted to a extra strategic, decision-making function.

In that scenario, you’re inheriting another person’s electronic mail technique, and chances are you’ll know subsequent to nothing about which campaigns are lively or how they’re performing. Auditing the present electronic mail program helps you get grasp of all the main points.

As you undergo the method, you’ll develop a transparent plan for making your mark and discover methods to implement your individual concepts to enhance the e-mail technique.

When E-mail Advertising Supervisor Julia Ritter began at Mailjet by Sinch, she carried out an audit and recognized the welcome emails as an automatic sequence that wanted updating.

After Sr. E-mail Developer Megan Boshuyzen took on a brand new function at E-mail on Acid by Sinch, she audited each template. Megan seen that there have been adjustments she may make to optimize code and handle darkish mode electronic mail challenges.

These two examples present that what will get audited could depend upon the individual doing the auditing and what they wish to discover out. Each electronic mail audit goes to be a bit totally different.

7 sorts of electronic mail audits

There are such a lot of transferring items related to the methods a company makes use of electronic mail, and that makes it troublesome to incorporate every thing in a single all-encompassing audit. Attempting to cowl all of it may even add to that overwhelming feeling.

Completely different sorts of electronic mail audits concentrate on particular areas. You may select a number of to incorporate in your analysis, relying in your wants and objectives.

Listed below are seven potentialities:

  1. E-mail advertising efficiency audit: That is the commonest kind. It usually examines the most-used key efficiency indicators (KPIs) to disclose the general well being of this system. On this article, we’ll be specializing in the steps required for an electronic mail efficiency audit.
  1. E-mail deliverability audit: This audit evaluates supply charges and appears for electronic mail deliverability issues and enhancements with infrastructure, electronic mail handle verification, electronic mail authentication protocols, and extra.
  1. E-mail design audit: This includes a evaluation of the design and improvement processes to find out the effectiveness and consistency of branding. Simply as importantly, it’s an opportunity to preview how design parts render in numerous electronic mail purchasers. It may additionally embrace updates to your electronic mail design system.
  1. E-mail automation audit: This consists of an evaluation of your triggered electronic mail campaigns equivalent to transactional emails and nurture tracks. Chances are you’ll uncover alternatives to automate much more. It might additionally contain an audit of current electronic mail templates that these automated emails are constructed with.
  1. E-mail compliance audit: This ensures entrepreneurs are following guidelines and greatest practices that shield the privateness and safety of subscribers. It may embrace evaluating adherence to rules, equivalent to Europe’s GDPR and CCPA in the USA.
  1. E-mail code audit: This is able to entail a code clean-up primarily based on present greatest practices for electronic mail improvement in addition to previewing and testing how electronic mail campaigns render on totally different purchasers like Gmail, Outlook, and Apple Mail.
  1. E-mail accessibility audit: Any such audit requires a evaluation of code and design parts to make sure that your messages are accessible to folks with disabilities equivalent to low imaginative and prescient and subscribers who use display readers to entry electronic mail.

It’s completely superb to mix sorts of electronic mail audits to satisfy your wants. Name it a Franken-audit, if you’ll. For instance, chances are you’ll wish to evaluation deliverability in an electronic mail efficiency audit. And an analysis of accessibility matches effectively with both an electronic mail design or code audit.

You possibly can additionally cut up the undertaking in different methods. Maybe you’ll wish to audit your transactional emails individually from advertising campaigns and electronic mail newsletters. The selection is as much as you. Simply make sure to outline these parameters earlier than you begin.

Who’s concerned in electronic mail auditing?

We’re going to exit on a limb right here and assume that, because you made it this far within the article, you are the one accountable for main the e-mail advertising audit. However no electronic mail marketer is an island.

Senior E-mail Entrepreneurs are likely to have robust common information on many trade subjects however might not be consultants in every thing. Don’t be afraid to ask for help from colleagues, company companions, or consultants.

Listed below are some locations to go for assist through the audit:

  • The IT division might help you with DNS data required for electronic mail authentication.
  • Designers and graphic artists can double-check visible branding towards their fashion information.
  • Content material entrepreneurs can counsel higher articles for buyer schooling.
  • Advertising analysts can present details about what occurs when electronic mail subscribers go to the web site.
  • Gross sales can inform you if the e-mail technique helps to nurture leads.


You’ll get higher outcomes in the event you enlist others within the group to assist out. And since these colleagues are aiding you within the electronic mail audit, they’ll be extra more likely to perceive precisely why sure adjustments have to be made.

Earlier than you start an electronic mail audit, establish the instruments that may assist every thing go easily. You’ll definitely have loads of choices – perhaps even too many. Advertising know-how and information sprawl can produce inconsistent stats. So, make sure to select a “supply of reality” for electronic mail metrics and keep it up.

These are a number of the sorts of instruments and software program typically utilized in an electronic mail audit:

  • E-mail service suppliers (ESPs)
  • Buyer Relationship Administration (CRM) software program
  • Buyer Information Platforms (CPDs)
  • Advertising Automation Platforms (MAPs)
  • E-mail testing instruments
  • Accessibility testing instruments
  • Sender fame testing and monitoring
  • Web site analytics instruments
  • Ecommerce reporting instruments


Your electronic mail service supplier (ESP) is an efficient place to begin. In the event you’re working with an ESP like Mailjet by Sinch, you need to use electronic mail monitoring instruments to collect statistics on each particular person emails and this system as an entire. As you brainstorm methods to replace electronic mail campaigns, it’s also possible to use collaboration instruments to work asynchronously as a staff.

Mailjet email tracking statistics
E-mail monitoring dashboard from Mailjet


Your ESP may be a spot to evaluation the outcomes of A/B exams on emails, which could possibly be utilized to different campaigns. Or, you may evaluation your checklist segmentation technique. Talking of electronic mail lists, the auditing course of is an efficient time to conduct some checklist hygiene.

Many different electronic mail platforms present helpful analytics for the auditing course of. That features reporting and electronic mail statistics from Mailjet, in addition to Mailgun by Sinch, and E-mail on Acid by Sinch.

A buyer relationship administration (CRM) resolution or advertising automation platform (MAP) can present you the way effectively electronic mail advertising is transferring prospects via the gross sales funnel.

In the event you’re evaluating electronic mail accessibility, there are a number of accessibility testing instruments that may assist. Operating your templates via an electronic mail pre-deployment platform helps you catch a wide range of points together with accessibility in addition to URL validation to robotically discover damaged hyperlinks (404 errors) and electronic mail previews to see how messages render on totally different purchasers and gadgets.

You may additionally wish to entry web site metrics and ecommerce stats from a supply like Google Analytics. Going past what occurs contained in the inbox helps you perceive electronic mail’s full affect on the enterprise.

The right way to conduct an electronic mail audit

Breaking the e-mail auditing course of down into distinct steps goes to make this undertaking extra manageable and far much less daunting. As talked about, we’re going to base our examples on an in depth electronic mail efficiency audit. Nevertheless, the steps shall be very related for all kinds of electronic mail audits.

1. Outline the objectives of your audit

There’s lots of information on the market and loads of components to think about. It’s straightforward to get distracted and head down a path that detracts from the aim of your electronic mail audit.

First, select the kind of audit you wish to conduct. Then, decide what you wish to study from the method. Once you end the e-mail advertising audit, what is going to you understand that you simply didn’t earlier than?

Many instances, an electronic mail audit is important as a result of there are particular issues that have to be solved or questions that want answering. Extra questions and concepts could emerge as you dig into the information. However attempt to keep targeted on the explanations you selected to do an audit – these are your main objectives. Write them all the way down to preserve you on observe.

2. Choose the fitting electronic mail metrics to judge

When you’ve outlined what you wish to study and attain, it’s time to pick the KPIs that may measure electronic mail efficiency and different components. Be sure you embrace electronic mail advertising metrics which can be underperforming so you may discover potential causes.

10 electronic mail metrics to think about to your audit:

  1. Complete variety of emails despatched/delivered
  2. Record development/whole variety of subscribers
  3. Unsubscribe price
  4. Open price and click-to-open price (CTOR)*
  5. Click on-through price (CTR)
  6. Conversion price
  7. Cellular vs. desktop
  8. Consumer and system breakdowns
  9. Engagement metrics (Learn, Skim, Look/Delete charges)
  10. Spam complaints

* Remember that Apple Mail Privateness Safety may make metrics related to opens much less dependable for subscribers who use that consumer.

Apart from the metrics, you’ll additionally have to assemble a spreadsheet that lists the identify of each electronic mail you might be evaluating. It could additionally embrace the launch date and the topic line.

3. Gather and compile information and observations

Get pleasant with that spreadsheet. The 2 of you’re going to be working collectively for some time. The best approach to create the sheet is to checklist electronic mail campaigns in rows and structure your metrics for every one in columns throughout the highest.

email marketing audit sample spreadsheet
E-mail audit spreadsheet structure instance


First, create a sheet for metrics that measures this system’s general metrics (all emails mixed). After you have got big-picture outcomes, you can begin drilling down. Contemplate separate spreadsheets for the next sorts of communications:


A “Notes” part for every row of your spreadsheet is one other good thought. As you compile the information, you’ll begin making observations and producing insights about what’s occurring with particular person emails.

What you’re doing right here is searching for outliers. Discover the campaigns that fall exterior of the norm as a result of sure electronic mail metrics are considerably larger or decrease than common. You’ll wish to take a better take a look at these emails.

4. Consider particular person emails

The following step of your electronic mail advertising audit is the place the actual investigation begins. All these metrics you gathered are your clues. The campaigns that stood out, for no matter motive, from others are your suspects. Now it’s time to get curious and clear up some mysteries.

Have a look at the numbers and ask your self “Why?” In our pattern spreadsheet above, chances are you’ll surprise why the product announcement bought lower-than-average engagement. May it’s as a result of the topic line “It’s lastly arrived” was too obscure? Or was there a deliverability difficulty? Perhaps send-time optimization would have helped.

The right way to audit electronic mail campaigns

As you consider marketing campaign efficiency through the audit, there are some key inquiries to ask when you contemplate totally different facets of the e-mail itself.

Inbox show questions:

  • Is the topic line clear and compelling?
  • Are you making the most of preheader textual content?
  • Do you have to be utilizing a unique “from” identify?


Though you could have seen these emails time and again, attempt to put your self within the footwear of a subscriber opening them for the primary time. Click on round and intently contemplate the e-mail expertise. Ask some colleagues to evaluation the e-mail expertise of essential campaigns too. And, in case you have the time and assets, conducting person testing offers you some real-world insights.

E-mail content material questions:

  • How does the design look?
  • Are you utilizing the fitting language and tone of voice?
  • Do you have got text-to-image ratio?
  • Are the calls-to-action getting clicked?
  • Does the e-mail observe model pointers?
  • Are you utilizing coloration distinction and headings for accessibility?
  • Is the content material featured within the electronic mail nonetheless related?
  • Are you linking to the very best touchdown web page?


In case you have a person expertise (UX) knowledgeable in-house, get some suggestions on problematic emails. You can too herald designers and writers to assist with the content material analysis. Heatmaps of emails present one other helpful approach to consider how subscribers expertise your campaigns.

E-mail improvement questions:

  • Are you utilizing clear and concise code?
  • How does the template render on totally different electronic mail purchasers and gadgets?
  • Are you implementing fallbacks when obligatory?
  • How does the e-mail render in darkish mode?
  • Do you employ semantic HTML for accessible emails?


In the event you’re unfamiliar with coding emails, ask an electronic mail developer to assist reply these questions.

E-mail advertising outcomes:

  • Did the e-mail obtain its supposed aim?
    • Ship site visitors to the web site
    • Enhance gross sales or enhance signups
    • Enhance model/product consciousness
    • Construct model loyalty
    • Inform/educate prospects
    • Scale back churn


You’ll doubtless have your individual set of questions primarily based on the objectives of your audit and the e-mail you’re reviewing. It might be useful to make use of an electronic mail audit guidelines you may observe, each for gathering data and electronic mail analysis.

5. Create a report in your findings

Congratulations! You’re nearly completed together with your electronic mail advertising audit. By now, it’s best to have some high-level insights in addition to smaller tactical adjustments you may make to enhance your model’s electronic mail technique.

In any case that tough work, it might be a disgrace to not share it. Don’t let all of your insights languish in spreadsheets. Put collectively some slides or a PDF which you can current and distribute all through the corporate. That features your electronic mail staff, the remainder of the advertising division, and different stakeholders who ought to see the outcomes.

Hold it easy and simple. The report doesn’t want to incorporate each single element – simply the most important takeaways. Attempt presenting your findings like this:

What’s Not Working? > Metrics > The Purpose > The right way to Repair It

What’s Working Properly? > Metrics >  The Purpose > The right way to Replicate It

Finally, the report in your electronic mail advertising audit will function a plan of assault with the subsequent steps and motion objects you’ll be pursuing within the months to return.

6. Take motion in your conclusions

Lastly, the quantity crunching and analysis is over, and it’s time to make some enhancements.

Simply as you don’t need to conduct an electronic mail audit alone, you shouldn’t have to repair every thing your self both. Be sure you delegate the fitting duties to the fitting folks. If there’s lots of work to do, you could possibly even use undertaking administration software program to arrange a board with assignments, directions, and deadlines.

In the event you want just a little extra inspiration and course earlier than implementing the findings of your electronic mail audit, obtain our free report, Inbox Insights 2022. You may discover survey outcomes from best-in-class electronic mail entrepreneurs, uncover rising electronic mail developments, and learn how to measure the success of your newly improved technique.

Feeling enthusiastic about what’s to return? Nice! However watch out about altering an excessive amount of too rapidly.

Check your adjustments

Whether or not it’s design, technique, segmentation, or some other issue, making sweeping adjustments could possibly be a mistake. That’s why you’ve bought to make incremental adjustments and check them out earlier than you leap to conclusions. You don’t wish to do extra hurt than good.

Cut up check your new topic traces and design updates towards the outdated variations of the emails. Check out new concepts on a small proportion of subscribers so you may see how they reply. Check and optimize for accessibility and deliverability. And, make sure to preview how up to date templates and new campaigns render on all main electronic mail purchasers.

There’s no motive to attend till the subsequent audit. Testing and monitoring aid you make steady enhancements to your electronic mail technique all 12 months lengthy.

Enhance your probabilities for electronic mail advertising success

Conducting an electronic mail advertising audit is definitely a time dedication, and we’re not saying it’ll be straightforward. But it surely’s well worth the effort, and it will likely be virtually painless the subsequent time since you’ve established a course of for getting the job achieved.

One other factor that improves electronic mail advertising success is entry to the fitting instruments and know-how. Our household of electronic mail advertising options is designed to present you an edge, they usually can all be used as assets throughout an electronic mail audit.

Mailgun affords cutting-edge electronic mail deliverability options and a strong API that integrates together with your functions. E-mail on Acid simplifies the method of launching campaigns with an automatic pre-send guidelines for testing, previews, and optimization. Right here at Mailjet, we offer an intuitive electronic mail builder that brings your concepts to life together with instruments to trace and cut up check your campaigns.

Improve Your 2022 Technique

Discover out what separates a super-successful electronic mail program from the remaining. Get your free copy of Inbox Insights 2022 to uncover the strategies and recommendation of best-in-class electronic mail entrepreneurs.

Obtain Now