Every September, PRSA acknowledges Ethics Month to deliver elevated consideration to the core basis of the communications occupation. Please go to prsa.org/ethics for added programming and ethics sources and PRSA’s social media platforms for updates all through the month.
In Could 2023, the U.S. Navy was criticized by quite a few lawmakers, veterans organizations and media retailers for its collaboration with an enlisted sailor and social media influencer who identifies as non-binary and performs as a feminine impersonator whereas off obligation. The sailor posts footage of those performances subsequent to pictures through which the sailor wears a Navy uniform whereas on obligation.
The Navy’s collaboration with Yeoman 2nd Class Joshua Kelley was a part of its Digital Ambassador Program, an effort to highlight service members with common social media accounts who the Navy deems as constructive representatives.
This system sought to achieve potential recruits in numerous demographic teams who want to obtain data from trusted social media influencers. Kelley, who makes use of the stage identify Harpy Daniels, was considered one of 5 members of the Navy’s pilot program that ran October 2022 to March 2023.
A few months later, in Could, the Navy started receiving pushback on-line from active-duty service members and veterans teams over its collaboration with Kelley. In June, America First Authorized, a conservative basis, charged that Kelley had violated the Uniform Code of Navy Justice “by participating in partisan politics, appearing disrespectfully towards superiors in public boards, bringing discredit upon the navy by means of obscene social media posts and carrying the uniform beneath circumstances that indicate Navy endorsement of private views and exercise.”
Greater than a dozen senators and a number of information retailers decried the Navy’s influencer program with Kelley. The Fiscal 12 months 2024 Nationwide Protection Authorization Act incorporates an modification to droop the Navy’s Digital Ambassador Program.
Supporters defended the Navy’s alternative, calling the sailor a constructive function mannequin who promotes range and inclusion. For my part, Kelley’s performances and social media model display that active-duty service members may also pursue off-duty passions as artists.
Nevertheless, the case illustrates the complexities that organizations face when collaborating with influencers. Skilled communicators may encounter the identical challenges when selling their organizations by way of assume tanks, tutorial intuitions, nonprofit organizations and conventional media. Nevertheless, protocols for working with influencers are nonetheless rising.
As lead communicator for the maritime arm of NATO, I supported an experiment final March to collaborate with a journey influencer named Jackie Todd, who has roughly 120,000 followers on Instagram and 650,000 followers on TikTok. NATO didn’t have insurance policies for influencer actions on a naval warship, so earlier than her go to, we extensively researched her on-line presence and made certain that each one stakeholders inside our unit and inside greater models supported the choice.
The profitable collaboration with this journey influencer produced a number of posts on two of her social media accounts, permitting us to achieve a youthful demographic of attainable recruits. NATO inspired us to pursue this chance and my workforce discovered some beneficial classes because of this.
Outline targets, expectations
First, we discovered to conduct intensive analysis on the influencer to keep away from any attainable indiscretions. Within the case of the Navy’s ambassador program, a cursory assessment of Kelley’s social media accounts may need found earlier posts that appeared to violate the Division of Protection’s insurance policies on service members’ political exercise.
Nevertheless, had the Navy communicated to the general public why it had chosen these 5 sailors for its ambassador program, it may need been capable of mitigate the ensuing blowback. The controversy over the Navy’s collaboration with Kelley underscores the significance of consulting with authorized, human sources and monetary departments and of creating certain that each one stakeholders are thought of earlier than deciding to work with a social media influencer.
Earlier than selecting an influencer, organizations must also outline what they anticipate to realize from the collaboration.
The navy as a complete faces a extreme recruiting disaster. The Navy’s determination to pick Kelley as an envoy not solely alienated some public affairs officers who’re presently serving, it additionally alienated veterans who’ve massive numbers of social media followers and may very well be the service’s most distinguished supporters to help recruitment.
I consider these discussions and issues are very important. My love of the Navy and the communication neighborhood conjures up me to candidly deal with this matter. Presently serving navy members can, on energetic obligation, respectfully name consideration to points they want to assist change. It’s how we “get actual and get higher,” the Navy’s name to motion for management growth and course of enchancment.
Like many organizations and establishments, the navy can’t afford to disregard the younger demographics that even Ramón “CZ” Colón-López, essentially the most senior non-commissioned officer within the armed forces, says we’d like social media influencers to assist attain, as a approach of accelerating recruitment.
Nevertheless, we should first contemplate all stakeholders and the potential pitfalls of this new communication medium. In any other case, we enter influencer partnerships at our peril. Not solely can they backfire and undermine the targets they’re supposed to realize, however collaborations with social media influencers may also tarnish the credibility of communicators and the organizations they serve.
Theresa Carpenter, APR+M is an active-duty public affairs officer for NATO Allied Maritime Command. The views expressed on this article are these solely of the creator and never of the Division of Protection or NATO. When off obligation, she is a navy content material creator and host of the S.O.S. (Tales of Service) podcast, the place she profiles change brokers and those that give again to their communities. Carpenter serves on PRSA’s Board of Ethics and Skilled Requirements. That is her third weblog for PRsay with reference to influencers. You’ll find all of her work right here.
[Photo credit: Adobe Art]